You are here

Multidirectional Instability M24.819 718.81


ICD-9 Classification / Treatment
Etiology / Epidemiology / Natural History Associated Injuries / Differential Diagnosis
Anatomy Complications
Clinical Evaluation Follow-up Care
Xray / Diagnositc Tests Review References

 synonyms: multidirectional instability, MDI



  • 718.31 Recurrent shoulder dislocation
  • 718.81 (other shoulder joint derangement, not elsewhere classified, instability of shoulder joint)

MDI Etiology / Epidemiology / Natural History

  • Global shoulder laxity (anterior, posterior and inferior) which produces symptoms inferiorly and in at least one other direction.
  • Multifactorial etiology; may include loose redundant inferior pouch, large rotator interval, aberrant muscle firing patterns, abnormal connective tissue, activity related demands, glenoid anatomy.
  • May have preceeding traumatic dislocation, repetitive microtrauma with overhead acitivity, or generalzed ligamentous laxity.
  • Gymnastics, volleyball, weightlifters, butterfly swimming, raquet/throwing sports may result in repetitive microtrauma and GH laxity.
  • Congenital etiologies: collagen disorders; Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, Marfans Syndrome. Often have family history
  • Generally younger than 35y/o.
  • Male = Female

MDI Anatomy

  • Glenohumeral stability is dependent on static (labrum, GH capular ligmants) and dynamic (RTC, deltoid, biceps, scapular musculature) restraints.
  • Inferior glenohumeral ligament (consist of anterior inferior GH ligamant, axillary pouch and posterior inferior GH ligament) is the most important for resisting anterior translation in the abducted arm.
  • Hidden lesions of the posterior labrum may be present (Kim SH, Arthroscopy 2004;20:712).
  • MDI patients frequently have a cleft in or absense of the rotator interval (Harryman DT, JBJS 1992;74A:53)

MDI Clinical Evaluation

  • Generally young, female athletes, c/o early fatigue, weakness, dead arm symptoms, pain, instability, weakness, paresthesias (inferior instability), popping, grinding, clicking.
  • Anterior instability=symptoms when in apprehension position such as cocking arm to throw (abduction, ER), reaching overhead, sleeping with arm overhead.
  • Posterior instability=slips out with forward elevation/IR such as removing book from overhead shelf, blocking for football linemen.
  • Interior instability=carrying heavy objects at side may also have traction paresthesias.
  • Generalized ligamentous laxity=hyperextension of elbows, knees, MCP joints, hyperabduction of thumb, patellofemoral laxity
  • Sulcus sign, load and shift, Push-pull test.
  • Evaluate for Scapular dyskinesia.
  • Assessments of generalized ligamentous laxity: ability to touch ipsilateral forearm with the thumb, place palms of hands on floor with knees locked, elbow/knee/MCP hyperextension.
  • Must rule out psychological problems/ voluntary dislocators!
  • Assess for history of Ehlers-Danlos or Marfan Syndrome.

MDI Xray / Diagnositc Tests

  • A/P and Lateral view in the plane of the scapula, and axillary view.
  • AP views in IR & ER, Stryker notch view, apical oblique view.  Evaluate for Bankart lesion and Hill-Sachs lesion. Glenoid hypoplasia/retroversion
  • West Point view: Useful for evaluating the anterior glenoid rim / bony Bankart lesions.
  • Hill-Sachs lesion: impression fracture of the posterosuperior aspect of the humeral head, produced by contact with the anteroinferior glenoid when dislocated. Hill-Sachs lesion is demonstrated on plain AP radiograph in internal rotation or Stryker notch view.

MDI Classification / Treatment

  • Initial treatment: 6 months physical therapy: RTC, deltoid, scapular stabilizer strengthening, improve proprioception, correct any abnormal muscle firing. >80% success rate. Nonsurgically treated young, athletic patients: 49% significant pain, 46% continued instability, 37% go on to have surgical treatment. By the modified Rowe grading scale 14% excellent results, 33% good, 53% poor results. (Misamore GW, JSES 2005;14:466).
  • Surgical treatment: arthroscopic capsular plication / rotator interval closure vs open anterior-inferior Capsular shift. Arthorscopic Capsular Plication: 97% good/excellent results (Kim SH, AJSM 2004;32:594).   Closure of the rotator interval has not been definitively shown to enhance stability or improve outcomes for patients with MDI.

MDI Associated Injuries / Differential Diagnosis

MDI Complications

  • Neurologic injury; 8.2% incidence after anterior reconstruction for recurrent GH instability. 78% recover completely. (Ho E, JSES 1999;8:266-270). Axillary nerve, Brachial plexus
  • Loss of ER, with eventual GH DJD.
  • Recurrent MDI
  • Pain
  • Hardware failure / Anchor pull-out
  • Infections
  • Stiffness
  • CRPS
  • Fluid Extravasation:
  • Chondrolysis: though to be related to heat from electo cautery or radiofrequency probes used during capsular release or capsular shrinkage.
  • Hematoma
  • Chondral Injury / arthritis
  • Instrument failure
  • Weakness

MDI Arthroscopic Plication Follow-up care

  • Post-op: shoulder immobilizer, remove dressing at 72 hrs, replace dressing, may shower if dry, replace dressing after each shower.
  • 7-10 Days: Pendelum exercises, passive FE with overhead pulley, gentle passive ER with a stick 4-6 times daily.  Limit of ER is determined at surgery.  Elbow wrist hand ROM. Sling contiuously for 2-3 weeks, with activity thereafter.
  • 6 Weeks: Advance to stregthening. Full active ROM.
  • 3 Months: Sport specific training.
  • 6 Months: Return to sport/heavy labor at 5-8months depending on regaining 90% of strength.
  • 1Yr: Mid-range stability is mainly dependent on muscular balance and coordination. Lifelong rehab program is required.
  • Shoulder Outcome measures

MDI Review References




The information on this website is intended for orthopaedic surgeons.  It is not intended for the general public. The information on this website may not be complete or accurate.  The eORIF website is not an authoritative reference for orthopaedic surgery or medicine and does not represent the "standard of care".  While the information on this site is about health care issues and sports medicine, it is not medical advice. People seeking specific medical advice or assistance should contact a board certified physician.  See Site Terms / Full Disclaimer